Keyshawn Johnson: Hall of Famer?

Keyshawn Johnson was a tremendous NFL wide receiver for a number of years, with his peak coming early in his career when he was arguably the best player at his position in 1998-99. He will serve as the prototype "possession receiver" in comparisons for years to come. If I could get a quarter for every time an analyst will compare a draft prospect to Keyshawn over the next decade, I'd end up with enough money to get a 'do from Mel Kiper's stylist.

Johnson was a hell of a player, simply put, but he was not a Hall of Famer. Especially if Art Monk--the original ultimate possession receiver--is not one.

Monk, who played from 1980-1995, outpaced Johnson in every major category:

-126 more receptions
-2150 more yards
-4 more receiving TDs
-.5 more yards per reception

The players had remarkably similar peaks, with both players having exactly five seasons of 980+ yards. Monk gained a little more yardage in his peak, while Johnson snagged a few more touchdown tosses. One could argue either way about era and team adjustments, but neither player played for the 2004-06 Colts, that's for sure.

Given that Johnson's career was remarkably similar to Monk's, I don't think Keyshawn will be able to escape the looming shadow of Monk's non-induction when judgment day comes for him.